Both options bring the same warm, natural look to a home, but the differences between them affect cost, durability, and maintenance more than most homeowners realize. Understanding cedar shakes vs cedar shingles helps homeowners choose the right wood roofing product for their budget and their climate instead of assuming the two terms mean the same thing. Many homeowners start comparing these options while exploring choices through a roofing service experienced with a range of wood roofing systems, which helps clarify which product actually fits their home. This guide breaks down the key differences between the two.

In this guide, you will learn:

  • Why cedar shakes and cedar shingles are often confused despite key differences
  • Six important differences between cedar shakes and cedar shingles
  • How each option performs in a mountain climate
  • How to decide which product fits your home and budget

Why a Real Cedar Roof Still Offers So Many Benefitscedar shakes vs cedar shingles repair brown new roof

Cedar shakes and cedar shingles are often used interchangeably in casual conversation, but they are manufactured differently and perform differently on a roof. Choosing real cedar over synthetic alternatives brings many benefits, and knowing the distinction between shakes and shingles helps homeowners avoid confusion when getting quotes or comparing materials.

  • Accurate cost comparisons: Contractors price shakes and shingles differently, so understanding the difference helps you compare quotes accurately.
  • Realistic expectations for appearance: Shakes and shingles create noticeably different textures and shadow lines on a finished roof.
  • Better maintenance planning: Each product has slightly different maintenance needs based on thickness and manufacturing method.
  • Informed climate decisions: One option may hold up better than the other under heavy snow and repeated freeze thaw cycles.
  • Clearer conversations with contractors: Using the correct terminology helps avoid miscommunication during the quoting and installation process.

Homeowners in Hungry Horse and surrounding areas weighing a wood roof often benefit from understanding this distinction early, since local climate conditions can make one option a better long term fit than the other.

6 Key Differences Between Cedar Shakes and Cedar Shingles

While both products come from cedar wood, the way they are cut and manufactured creates meaningful differences in appearance, cost, and performance.

1. Manufacturing Method

Cedar shingles are sawn on both sides, giving them a smooth, uniform, tapered appearance. Cedar shakes, on the other hand, are typically split by hand or machine to create a rougher, more rustic texture with more natural variation.

  • Shingles have a consistent, machine cut appearance
  • Shakes have a more irregular, textured surface due to the splitting process
  • The manufacturing method directly influences the final look of the roof

2. Thickness

Cedar shakes are generally thicker than cedar shingles, which affects both appearance and durability. Thicker material tends to provide a more substantial, dimensional look on the finished roof.

  • Shakes commonly range from three quarters of an inch to over an inch thick
  • Shingles are typically thinner and more uniform in thickness
  • Thicker shakes can offer slightly better insulation properties due to added mass

3. Cost and Installation Process Differences

Because of the additional labor and material involved in producing shakes, they typically cost more than cedar shingles for the same square footage. This cost difference extends to the installation process as well, since shakes often require more time to install correctly.

  • Shakes generally cost more per square than shingles
  • Installation labor for shakes can also run higher due to the material’s thickness and texture
  • Shingles offer a more budget friendly way to achieve a wood roof appearance

4. Weather Performance

Both products perform well when properly installed and maintained, but their different thicknesses and textures affect how they handle wind, snow, and moisture. Shakes tend to offer slightly more resistance to wind uplift due to their weight and thickness.

  • Thicker shakes generally shed heavy snow loads a bit more effectively
  • Shingles rely more heavily on proper installation and overlap for weather resistance
  • Both materials need adequate ventilation underneath to prevent moisture related issues

5. Regular Maintenance Needscedar roof damaged cedar shake roof repair

While both products require similar regular maintenance, such as periodic cleaning and treatment, the rougher surface of shakes can trap more debris and moisture than the smoother surface of shingles.

  • Shakes may need more frequent cleaning to prevent moss and debris buildup in their textured surface
  • Shingles’ smoother surface tends to shed water and debris more easily
  • Both products benefit from periodic water repellent or fungicide treatments

6. Aesthetic Appeal and Curb Appeal

The most noticeable difference between shakes and shingles is the overall look they create on a finished roof. Shakes produce a rustic, textured, dimensional appearance, while shingles offer a cleaner, more uniform look.

  • Shakes are often chosen for a more rugged, cabin style aesthetic
  • Shingles suit homes looking for a tidier, more traditional wood roof appearance
  • Both options weather to a similar silvery gray patina over time if left untreated

Choosing the Right Option for a Mountain Climate

Beyond appearance and cost, climate performance plays an important role in deciding between cedar shakes and cedar shingles, especially for homeowners dealing with heavy snow and seasonal moisture.

Snow Load Considerations

Thicker cedar shakes generally handle heavy snow accumulation slightly better than thinner shingles, though proper installation matters more than material choice alone. A cedar shake roof in particular benefits from careful attention to overlap and fastening in areas with heavy winter accumulation. Homeowners in Hungry Horse and surrounding areas dealing with significant winter snowfall should discuss snow load performance directly with their contractor.

Ventilation Needs

Both shakes and shingles require adequate attic and roof ventilation to prevent trapped moisture from causing premature rot. This need is especially pronounced in climates with repeated freeze thaw cycles, where trapped moisture has more opportunities to cause damage.

Fire Rating Considerations

Untreated cedar, whether in shake or shingle form, carries a higher fire risk than many alternative materials. Fire retardant treatments are available for both products and may be required depending on local building codes.

  • Ask your contractor whether treated products are required or recommended for your area
  • Fire treated products may qualify for different insurance terms
  • Both shakes and shingles can achieve improved fire ratings with the right treatment

Energy Efficiency Benefits of a Cedar Roof

A cedar roof, whether made from shakes or shingles, offers natural energy efficiency benefits that many homeowners overlook when comparing wood roofing to other materials. The natural insulating properties of wood help regulate indoor temperatures, which can translate into modest savings on heating and cooling over time.

  • Wood’s natural cellular structure provides better insulation than many manufactured materials
  • Thicker shakes offer a slight edge in insulating value compared to thinner shingles
  • Energy efficiency benefits work best when paired with proper attic insulation and ventilation

Long Term Performance in a Mountain Setting

Both cedar shakes and cedar shingles can last several decades when properly installed and maintained, but the harsher conditions found near Hungry Horse and surrounding areas tend to shorten that timeline compared to milder climates. Repeated freeze thaw cycles, heavy snow accumulation, and intense summer sun all place extra demands on wood roofing.

  • Regular inspections help catch early signs of wear before they spread
  • Periodic treatments help both products maintain their natural resistance to moisture and decay
  • Homeowners who stay consistent with maintenance often see their roof outperform the average lifespan for the material

Cedar Shakes vs Cedar Shingles: A Side by Side ComparisonCedar Shake Roofing light grey roof

Comparing the two products directly can help homeowners make a more confident decision based on their priorities.

Factor Cedar Shakes Cedar Shingles
Appearance Rustic, textured, dimensional Smooth, uniform, tailored
Thickness Thicker, more substantial Thinner, more consistent
Cost Higher material and labor cost More budget friendly
Maintenance Slightly more frequent cleaning needed Easier to keep clean
Best suited for Rustic or cabin style homes Traditional or classic style homes
  • Budget priority: Homeowners focused on cost may lean toward shingles for a similar wood look at a lower price point.
  • Aesthetic priority: Homeowners wanting a bold, rustic texture often prefer the dimensional look of shakes.
  • Long term maintenance: Consider how much upkeep you are willing to commit to when weighing the two options.
  • Climate performance: Discuss local snow load and moisture concerns with a contractor familiar with wood roofing in your area.

Homeowners near Hungry Horse and surrounding areas often find that the decision comes down to balancing aesthetic preference against budget, since both products can perform well in a mountain climate when properly installed and maintained.

It can also help to think about how the roof will look years down the road rather than only how it looks on installation day. Both shakes and shingles weather to a similar silvery gray tone over time, but the deeper grooves and shadow lines on shakes tend to age in a way that many homeowners find still looks intentional and rustic, while the smoother surface of shingles ages into a cleaner, more understated look.

 

Making a Confident Choice for Your Wood Roof

Understanding the differences between cedar shakes and cedar shingles helps homeowners choose the option that best fits their budget, aesthetic goals, and local climate demands. Whether your priorities lean toward cedar shakes and shingles that offer a bolder texture or a cleaner, more traditional look, neither option is universally better than the other, and the right choice depends on your specific priorities for the project.

If you are weighing cedar shakes against cedar shingles for your home, our team can walk you through the pros and cons based on your specific goals and location. Montana Roofing has helped homeowners throughout the region choose and install wood roofing systems built to handle Montana winters. Reach out and contact us today to talk through your options and get honest guidance on which product fits your home and your goals best.

 

Share This Article

Mariah Fuchsel

Author